70 CM Capitalism Command Control Kritik -...

Capitalism/Command and Control
DDI ‘08
Clark-Martin
Capitalism and Command and Control
Table of Contents
Capitalism and Command and Control .................................................................................................................. 1
Table of Contents ........................................................................................................................................................ 1
1NC Shell ...................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1NC Shell ...................................................................................................................................................................... 5
1NC Shell ...................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Link- Permits (Same as 1NC link just retagged) .................................................................................................... 7
Link – Ecology = Opium for the Masses .................................................................................................................. 8
Link- Restructuring Capital ...................................................................................................................................... 9
Link- Restructuring Capital .................................................................................................................................... 10
Impact- Cap Kills Animal/Human Rights ............................................................................................................. 12
Impact- Cap  Nuke War ...................................................................................................................................... 14
Impact- Environmental Destruction + Cap Collapse Inevitable ....................................................................... 15
Impact- Cap  Eco Extinction ............................................................................................................................... 16
Impact- Cap  Extinction by Environment ........................................................................................................ 17
Impact- Environment Destruction ......................................................................................................................... 18
..................................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Impact- Cap Kills Developing World Environment  Death ........................................................................... 19
Impact- Cap Biggest Threat to World ................................................................................................................... 20
Alt- Pedagogy ............................................................................................................................................................. 21
Alt- Pedagogy ............................................................................................................................................................. 22
Alt- Pedagogy ............................................................................................................................................................. 24
Alt- Animal Rights .................................................................................................................................................... 25
Turn- Cap Increases Emissions (Trading Specific) ............................................................................................. 27
Turn- Econ Reform  More Exploitation ........................................................................................................... 28
Cap Root Cause/Plan Disguises Blame .................................................................................................................. 29
Cap Root Cause/Plan Disguises Blame .................................................................................................................. 30
No Solvency- Cap Solutions Fail ............................................................................................................................. 31
Cap Kills Eco/A2 Trade = No war .......................................................................................................................... 32
A2 Perm/Work Within System ............................................................................................................................... 33
A2 Perm/Work Within System ............................................................................................................................... 34
1

Capitalism/Command and Control
DDI ‘08
Clark-Martin
AFF- Cap  Peace .................................................................................................................................................... 35
AFF- Capitalism Key to World Peace ................................................................................................................... 37
Aff- Cap Key Environ .............................................................................................................................................. 38
..................................................................................................................................................................................... 38
AFF- Capitalism Moral ........................................................................................................................................... 39
Aff- Cap Inevitable ................................................................................................................................................... 42
..................................................................................................................................................................................... 42
Counterplan ............................................................................................................................................................... 43
Counterplan 1NC Shell ............................................................................................................................................ 44
Trading Systems Fail ................................................................................................................................................ 45
Trading Systems Fail ................................................................................................................................................ 46
Trading Systems Fail ................................................................................................................................................ 47
Trading Systems Fail ................................................................................................................................................ 48
Trading Systems Fail- Tech ..................................................................................................................................... 49
Trading Systems Fail- Tech ..................................................................................................................................... 50
Trading Systems Fail- Environment ...................................................................................................................... 51
Trading Systems Fail- Fiscal/Inefficient ................................................................................................................ 52
Trading Systems Fail- Corruption ......................................................................................................................... 53
Trading Systems Fail- Corruption ......................................................................................................................... 54
Trading Systems Fail- Future ................................................................................................................................. 55
Trading Systems Fail- Change ................................................................................................................................ 56
Trading Systems Fail- Transparency ..................................................................................................................... 57
Trading Systems Fail- Unorganized ....................................................................................................................... 59
Trading Systems Fail ................................................................................................................................................ 60
Command and Control Good/Trade Bad .............................................................................................................. 61
Command and Control Good/Trade BAd ............................................................................................................. 62
Command and Control Good/Trade Bad .............................................................................................................. 63
Command and Control Best .................................................................................................................................... 64
Command and Control Best- Context ................................................................................................................... 65
Command and Control Best- Numbers ................................................................................................................. 66
Market Shift Kills C and C ...................................................................................................................................... 67
Emission Taxes Fail .................................................................................................................................................. 68
2

Capitalism/Command and Control
DDI ‘08
Clark-Martin
AFF- C and C fails .................................................................................................................................................... 69
Aff- C and C fails- adaptation ................................................................................................................................. 70
Aff- C and C fails- Outdated ................................................................................................................................... 71
AFF- Command and Control Worst ...................................................................................................................... 73
Aff- Market Good/CAC bad .................................................................................................................................... 74
Right To Pollute Net Benefit ................................................................................................................................... 75
.................................................................................................................................................................................... 75
Shell ............................................................................................................................................................................. 76
Shell ............................................................................................................................................................................. 77
Shell ............................................................................................................................................................................. 78
Tradable Permits = Indulgences ............................................................................................................................. 79
..................................................................................................................................................................................... 82
Tradable Permits  Pollution ................................................................................................................................ 82
Tradable Permits  Exploitation .......................................................................................................................... 83
Environ/Nature Risk of Despoliation ..................................................................................................................... 84
Kritik Alt- Zero Pollution ........................................................................................................................................ 85
3

Capitalism/Command and Control
DDI ‘08
Clark-Martin
1NC Shell
Economic incentives that encourage ecological reform destroys more radical
environmentalist movements and results in the expansion of capitalism, as the environment
is commodified and reframed as a source of profit.
(David Parker and Barry Larsen , January 23 20 08 , “An ecosocialist critique of sustainable
development: maintaining growth through sustainable degradation”
http://wellsharp.wordpress.com/2008/01/23/an-ecosocialist-critique-of-sustainable-development-
maintaining-growth-through-sustainable-degradation)