{[ promptMessage ]}

Bookmark it

{[ promptMessage ]}

60 BQ USPS Hydrogen Case Neg

60 BQ USPS Hydrogen Case Neg - USPS Hydrogen Neg DDI 2008...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–4. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
USPS Hydrogen Neg DDI 2008 BQ    Steve Quam USPS Neg USPS Neg ...................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Strat… Fo You ........................................................................................................................................................... 3 T – Substantial ............................................................................................................................................................. 4 T- Exts ........................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Counterplans ................................................................................................................................................................ 6 Efficiency CP - Solvency ............................................................................................................................................ 7 Efficiency CP - Solvency ............................................................................................................................................ 8 Efficiency CP – Solvency ............................................................................................................................................ 9 Efficiency CP – Solvency .......................................................................................................................................... 10 States CP – Solvency ................................................................................................................................................. 11 States CP – Solvency ................................................................................................................................................. 12 States CP - Solvency ................................................................................................................................................. 13 States CP - Solvency ................................................................................................................................................. 14 DA Links .................................................................................................................................................................... 15 PTix Links – Obama Good ...................................................................................................................................... 16 PTix Links – Obama Good ...................................................................................................................................... 17 PTix Links – McCain Good ..................................................................................................................................... 18 Oil Link ....................................................................................................................................................................... 19 BizCon Link ............................................................................................................................................................... 20 Fiscal D Link .............................................................................................................................................................. 21 EU Trade Link .......................................................................................................................................................... 22 WTO Link .................................................................................................................................................................. 23 Case ............................................................................................................................................................................. 24 Solvency Frontline .................................................................................................................................................... 25 Solvency Frontline .................................................................................................................................................... 26 Solvency Exts ............................................................................................................................................................. 27 Warming Frontline ................................................................................................................................................... 28 Warming Frontline ................................................................................................................................................... 29 1
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
USPS Hydrogen Neg DDI 2008 BQ    Steve Quam Warming Frontline ................................................................................................................................................... 30 Ice Age DA ................................................................................................................................................................. 31 Ice Age DA ................................................................................................................................................................. 32 Oil Dependence Frontline ........................................................................................................................................ 33 Oil Dependence Frontline ........................................................................................................................................ 34 Oil Dependence Frontline ........................................................................................................................................ 35 Hegemony Bad ........................................................................................................................................................... 36 Hegemony Bad ........................................................................................................................................................... 37 Hegemony Bad ........................................................................................................................................................... 38 Hydrogen Space Militarization .......................................................................................................................... 39 Space Militarization Bad ......................................................................................................................................... 40 Space Militarization Bad ......................................................................................................................................... 41 2
Background image of page 2
USPS Hydrogen Neg DDI 2008 BQ    Steve Quam Strat… Fo You  Smeared black ink... your palms are sweaty And I'm barely listening to last demands… The Postal Service, but no this is not an aff to jack the popular indie pop band up on hydrogen. Rather it remakes the United States Postal Service (USPS) into a fleet of hydrogen vehicles. The reason that this would be a good idea because the plan would allow hydrogen vehicles (hydrocars) to become cost competitive. Right now there is no infrastructure for hydrocars as you know. The USPS is everywhere though so if all their cars became hydrogen the government would be forced to make hydrogen-refueling stations all over the place. This is how the aff claims to create a “hydrogen-economy”. Here are the aff advantages: Oil Dependency: Oil Impacts Hege Good Impacts Warming: Warming Bad We have several args against the aff. We have defense on both, which you should read. E.g. oil dependency inevitable, warming not happening, warming inevitable, hege inevitably declining. We also have some offense you can read. On the hege part you can read hege bad, and on warming you can read the ice age DA. You’ll want to make sure that you have extensions for these. On solvency you will want to argue that the timeframe is too long (especially since they use a special sugar based hydrogen). Also, hydrogen is expensive not effective etc. I just cut a new space arg that is HAWT. We have a card that says hydrogen leads to space militarization and then we say space mil bad. The space mil bad cards are hawt; here is an example from on of them: “ If the U.S. proceeds with its plans to weaponize space, the chances of a cataclysmic nuclear holocaust will be real and not far over the horizon” Yeah you can read that too. Counterplans: In this file solvency has been included for the efficiency CP and states. Both of these solve quite well. Both of the advs depend on not using oil as much. Efficiency solves this well, and the cards on the subject are good. The timeframe for the CP is quicker then it is for the aff as well. A NB to efficiency could be either spending or politics, since feebates (solvency mechanism for
Background image of page 3

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Image of page 4
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

{[ snackBarMessage ]}