301 BQ Consult Natives Neg Arguments

301 BQ Consult Natives Neg Arguments - Consult Natives Neg...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Consult Natives Neg Arguments DDI 2008 <B/Q>    Goldie (FDS, SDS, DDS) Strategy Notes- .......................................................... 3 Aight check it out Gorla bears, I have written out extensions for you and 2nc/1nr evidence to back up why binding consultation works. They can be used to answer specific strategies the 2ac uses, or you can go through it your self and create your own 1nc. Now for the analytics they should be used with a piece of evidence and not by yourself however for adaptation purposes I did not take the time to insert a certain card, that is left up to you. Now it gets more confusing when you get down to eligibility, however the basic argument is that the affirmative consults tribes on reservations who use blood quantum’s which are evil (look to the Churchill evidence for back up to this point). However there is a trap in the cards if everyone is eligible shouldn’t we consult everyone? The answers to these questions are as follows: Well first were only consulting natives in which you plan to incentive alternative energy thus no. What else is consultation should be consensus making or should be representatives of that first nation, who engage with the United States Federal Government. They might trap you on this one, but decision making across grass roots movements usually involves representatives and not every single person. However quick side note the Zapatistas down in Chiapas, Mexico. took eight years to decide on their name because they had to ask everyone, (so it’s really up to you). I feel to be honest with you I would try and avoid the eligibility debate in less the affirmative brings it up, but I’m hoping you had already figured that out from my description. ................ 3 Analytics ................................................................ 4 4. Turn/ you buy into corporations as much we do you are not creating a de-centralized system of energy but a system that works hand in hand with corporations and natives. ................................................ 4 Consultation Non-Binding ................................................. 5 A2: There has been Policy Change ......................................... 6 A2 :Consultation Happening Now .......................................... 7 Consultation happens now ................................................. 8 Consultation Important ................................................... 9 Non-Binding Bad ......................................................... 10 Non-Binding Bad ......................................................... 11 Environmental protection ................................................ 12 Status Quo Consultation=Bureaucratic mess ............................... 13 Consultations=Negotiations .............................................. 14 Binding Consultations= Movements ........................................ 15 1
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
Consult Natives Neg Arguments DDI 2008 <B/Q>    Goldie (FDS, SDS, DDS) Must Work Under Binding Framework
Background image of page 2
Image of page 3
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Page1 / 33

301 BQ Consult Natives Neg Arguments - Consult Natives Neg...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 3. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online