Indares y Martignioli, 1985

Indares y Martignioli, 1985 - Canadian Mineralogist (1985)...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–2. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Canadian Mineralogist Yol. 23, pp. 187-193 (1985) BIOTITE-GARNET GEOTHERMOMETRY IN GRANULITE-FACIES ROCKS: EVALUATION OF EOUILIBRIUM CRITERIA APHRODITE INDARES AND JACQTIES MARTIGNOLE Ddportement de gdologie, Universitd de Montrdal, Case postale 6128, succursale A, Montrdal, Qudbec H3C 317 biotite and garnet can be modeled in the AKFM sys- tem by the exchange reaction: %Fe3Al2Si3O12 * 7:KMg3 AlSi3Oro(OH)2 : almandine phlogopite %Mg3Al2Si3Op+%KFe3AlSi3Oro(OH)2 (l) pyrope annite The corresponding equilibrium-constant Kis equiva- lent to a distribution coefficient Ko equal to (FelMg)uil@e/Mg)uu provided both solid solutions are ideal. In rocks, however, incorporation of minor elements commonly results in a departure from ideal- ity in both biotite and garnet solid-solutions, so that Ko may significantly deviate from K. In the last ten years, several calibrations ofKp as a function of T have been used as geological thermometers, each one adopting a different model for minor-element inter- action. Among these calibrations, Spear (1978), Goldman & Albee (1978) and Thomp- son (1976) have been extensively used, but appear to give inconsistent results if applied to granulite- variation in Ko may occur within a single area or even a single thin-section without significant varia- tion in concentration of minor elements @erkins el al. 1982, Indares 1982). For a given calibration, these variations in Kp lead to a large span of estimated temperature. Several authors (e.g., Tracy et al. 1976) have stressed the role of local re-equilibration during cool- ing from peak temperatures to account for such var- iations in Kp. Consequently, a narrow contact-zone between adjacent minerals is usually to be avoided in electron-microprobe analysis. Nevertheless, com- positional heterogeneity is not limited to mineral con- tacts, and several types of Kp can be calculated, probably conesponding to compositions of quenched local equilibrium. The aim of rhis paper is to demon- strate that a judicious selection of biotite and gar- net grains, as well as the selection of targets within a given grain, provides chemical data (and thus Kp values) referring to specific temperatures attained during peak conditions or to certain stages of cool- ing. In a separate paper, which takes into account the conclusions of this contribution and the effects of nonideality in both biotite and garnet solid- solutions, a new biotite-garnet thermometric calibra- t87 AssrRAcr Most commonly accepted calibrations of the biotite- garnet geothermometer have yielded inconsistent estimates of the temperature of the rocks in the granulite facies. This type of inconsistency, unrelated to the calibration, can be avoided by selecting particular minerals and specific loca- tions for analysis within these minerals so that the calcu-
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
Image of page 2
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Page1 / 7

Indares y Martignioli, 1985 - Canadian Mineralogist (1985)...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 2. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online