John walks to the store every day b john walked to

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: s of dura/on, intensity and tendency 8 •  Whorf observed linguis/c differences between Hopi and ‘Standard Average European’ (SAE), e.g. •  Use of cardinal numbers with /me (e.g. ten days) •  Expression of ‘phases’ (e.g. ‘tomorrow’) • The tense system •  Expressions of dura/on, intensity and tendency 9 Tense a. John walks to the store (every day) b. John walked to the store (yesterday) 10 •  Whorf: ‘Hopi may be called a /meless language [….] is does not dis/nguish between present, past and future of the event itself [….]’ 11 •  Pinker’s (1994:53) reply: ‘What then are we to make of the following sentence translated from Hopi? (from the work of anthropologist Ekkehart Malkt) – Then indeed, the following day, quite early in the morning at the hour when people pray to the sun, around that 7me then he woke up the girl again . 12 •  The fallacy in Whorf’s reasoning stems from the following two assump/ons: – A) the language does not provide other means to make the dis/nc/on – B) that the speaker of the language treat the exis/ng categories as the basis for non ­linguis/c thought 13 •  Compare: –  A) English: ‘it’ for babies –  B) English: ‘she’ for ships –  C) German: Mädchen (Neut.) –  D) Mandarin Chinese: ‘ta’ –  E) Chinese: tenselessness –  F) English: past/non ­past vs. future 14 Eskimo words for snow •  Whorf on eskimo words for snow: – ...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 04/03/2012 for the course LINGUISTIC LIN200 taught by Professor Naominagy during the Spring '10 term at University of Toronto- Toronto.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online