This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.
Unformatted text preview: . Martino,
was entering the country from Haiti with approximately $ 234,000. Marino, who was
involved in a conspiracy to rob passengers carrying large sums of money into the United
States, had Mr. Martino robbed at gunpoint.
This case proceeded to trial and during closing argument, Dade County's counsel made
several, unobjected to comments. For example, during closing argument, he argued as
So this verdict will ring out through the State of Florida and it will say, hey, Dade County
is really vulnerable in these negligent hiring cases and we are going to start now every
time an employee steals something, every time an employee assaults somebody, you are
going to have a dearth of lawsuits here. This is a signal case and I will tell you right now
it was I, me, Mr. Sikes who decided to try this lawsuit based upon my recommendation to
In addition, he also argued as follows:
You know, I don't dislike Mr. Martino. He kind of got mad [**3] with me when I was
talking to me [sic]. I didn't mean to make him mad.
I wanted to find out where he got those dollars. Those companies had to be doing a whole
lot of business in two months because we went back months before - we went back years
before and he was bringing in five, $ 6,000, $ 20,000 and then one shipment $ 336,000.
A million dollars. Over a million dollars in two months.
Also, in reference to the plaintiffs' only expert witness, Kenneth Harms, the former Chief
of Police of the City of Miami Police Department, Dade County's counsel argued as
That's what Harms needs. Harms needs one of those tall hats that they wear down in the
Banana Republic. The guy that has got all the braids. He is the guy whose a dictator
because it's Harm's law.
Plaintiffs now argue that these comments and others constituted fundamental error
requiring reversal. A contemporaneous objection to improper comments is necessary to
preserve error, unless the error is fundamental. Brumage v. Plummer, 502 So. 2d 966, 5 968 (Fla....
View Full Document
- Spring '08