This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.
Unformatted text preview: en Elect oral College t hought not t o be appropriat e: such penalt ies disproport ionat ely affect t he poor, Env ironment al Prot ect ion and can lead t o heav y cost s on an elect oral commission". (11) But ev en where t hat is t rue, it is import ant t o realise t hat people
can, and do, go t o prison for failing t o Est at e Tax pay fines, and t hat t his is t he case, as well, for t hose who fail t o pay fines for nonv ot ing. For example, in 1999 Melissa Manson was European Union sent enced t o one day in prison
for failing t o pay t he fines incurred by her failure t o v ot e in t he 1993 and 1996 Eut hanasia
Federal Reserv e
All Big Issues Federal elect ions. Manson, apparent ly , believ ed t hat t here were no candidat es
wort h v ot ing for, and t herefore object ed bot h t o v ot ing, and t o pay ing t he
result ing fine, on principle.(H ill, 6 " 7 and 17) Before holding t hat compulsory
v ot ing is just ified, t herefore, we need t o be prepared t o make criminals of people
who do not pay t heir fines for not v ot ing " and need t o be confident t hat doing so
is consist ent wit h t he democrat ic v alues and object iv es t hat animat e t his case for
compulsion. If compulsory v ot ing is inst it ut ed t he aff agrees t o inforce laws t hat
infringe on peoples right s.
It is for all t hese reasons t hat I must negat e t oday s resolut ion.
Repo rt this Argument I hereby st at e t hat t he opinions st at ed below and t he argument s present ed do not necessarily dict at e my personal
P ro As commonly proposed, democracy is of t he...
View Full Document
This document was uploaded on 01/16/2014.
- Winter '14