Bobic-and-Davis-A-Kind-Word-for-Theory-X

Mcgregor often drew on the works of chris argyris

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: McGregor 1966, 43; 1967, 10–11); however, he soon began to focus on intrinsic or internal motivations for behavior. McGregor often drew on the works of Chris Argyris, Frederick Herzberg, and others who believed that manager-subordinate relationships should be understood as social constructs or complex role interactions (1960, 32, 55, 173, 186–88; 1967, 76). By the time McGregor began work on THSE, he had encountered the work of Abraham Maslow. Maslow’s work not only supported McGregor’s own ideas about a hierarchy of motivation (McGregor in Bennis, Schein, and McGregor 1966, 22, 40, 44), it provided a stronger theoretical foundation for McGregor’s work (1960, 35–37, 67; 1967, 75; McGregor in Bennis, Schein, and McGregor 1966, 43, 52–135).1 McGregor relied upon a number of theories, including social constructivism, to explain the manager-subordinate relationship and its pathologies. However, both internal and external evidence support the central importance of Maslow’s hierarchy to McGregor’s new theory of management. McGregor states in THSE that Maslow’s hierarchy was central to his work (1960, 36– 40). He noted that its key concepts (particularly self-actualization) were “central to my view of appropriate managerial strategy” (1967, 75) and critical to the success of the Scanlon Plan (quoted in Bennis, Schein, and McGregor 1966, 135). He often referred to fulfilling higher-order needs as part of management (1960, 37, 67; 1967, 75–77; McGregor in Bennis, Schein, and McGregor 1966, 43, 52, 135). Scholars almost exclusively interpret McGregor in terms of Maslow’s hierarchy as well. Twenty-eight of the thirty-four most popular management texts discussed McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y directly in relation to Maslow. None of the twenty-four texts that discussed social construct theory mentioned McGregor. 1 241 242 Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory Figure 1 Maslow’s Heirarchy of Needs. Image provided by Chris Jarvis, of the Business On Line Archives, Brunell University. Used by Permission. http://sol.brunel.ac.uk/~jarvis/bola/motivation/masmodel.html Self actualization Esteem, status Social, affection Safety, security, order Physiological needs Maslo...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 01/22/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online