Bobic-and-Davis-A-Kind-Word-for-Theory-X

The principle holds that the latter generally produce

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: person had the capacity to be innovative and to see problems differently. The following research indicates that creativity is a much more complicated concept. Creativity as a Multidimensional Concept Certainly creativity involves innovation or breaking molds, but modern personality theorists argue that creativity may also be reflected in adaptive behavior as well. This theory, known as “requisite diversity,” argues that maladaptive species fail because there are too few members using various creative models in order to adapt to rapid changes in their environment. Bobic, Davis, and Cunningham (1999) provided a review of the relevant works developing the concept of requisite diversity. Social scientists have adapted the concept of requisite diversity to argue that organizations dominated by a single type of personality or work style are inferior to ones that are balanced or contain a diversity of work styles (Kirton 1989b). The principle holds that the latter generally produce a superior product or service.7 Michael Kirton has done substantial work in the field of requisite diversity and creativity, and his work contradicts much of Maslow indicated that different kinds of management may be necessary in different circumstances. “Theory Y principles hold primarily for good conditions, rather than for stormy weather” (Maslow 1998, xxiii). McGregor’s research indicates that personality, not circumstance, determines style. 7 251 252 Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory Maslow’s (and McGregor’s) work, as do Bobic, Davis, and Cunningham (1999). What follows is a brief overview of Kirton’s research. Adapters and Innovators Kirton believed that when people confronted problems or were asked to resolve a conflict or task, they had certain habitual characteristic modes of behavior (Kirton 1989b, 5). People either reacted by adapting to changed circumstances or by innovating, finding different or unorthodox solutions to these new circumstances. “Every individual can be located on a continuum on which the habitual Adapter and the habitual Innovator are at...
View Full Document

Ask a homework question - tutors are online