Wood___Roberts_2011_Tradional_Economic_G

Central place theory thus represents a combination o

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: as well as regional scientists and planners, refined Christaller's ideas about urban hierarchies. O ne o f the most well known results o f their efforts is the 'rank size rule' derived from arranging urban centers, o r central places in Christaller's terms, into a rank order based o n size. The rank size rule hold~ that i f cities in a region o r c ountry are ranked in descending order size o f total DODulation, t he size o f the populations o f 1.0 the lower ranked cities a nd towns will be proportional to that o f the largest or top ranked city. Furtllermore, the rank size rule indicates that the largest city will be twice the size o f t he second largest; t hat t he second largest city will be three times the size o f the third and so on, generating a linear pattern, as s hown in Figure 2.10. The rank size rule, while i t is clearly more descriptive than explanatoty, spurred a series o f investigations in postwar decades (e.g., Z ipf 1949) into the functioning o f u rban hierarchies through an examination o f tbe flows o f people, commodi­ ties a nd i nformation between them. Chapter 3 provides more details o f this particular sort ofeconomic geography. I t has often been observed that Christaller's central place theory 'fits' certain regions better than others. As his book's title clearly indicates, he worked o ut the specifics o f his theory by reference t o southern Germany and the book's appendix contains data, tables and maps o f the region (Figure 2.11). 1 07 ® ® 'Ideal' rank ;/' size rule 106 .~united . """ States ~."\ (states) 0 ~ ~ u ."".". • 0.2 '* E .9 1: CIJ c ,, , \ \ \ .~ c. ,, - - United States - ---- Sweden World ' • (72 countries) 0.1 \ !1J \ c ~1Q5 !lJ \ , ~-, ~ CIJ ,, ' ...... 7& <D .!::! ~ • IX \ Qi % '" '0 ",\5'& ,, ( f) 0 /..9 \ 104 ~~tstralja , ", ,, ,, \ates) \ \ 0.02 I 1 \ I". • 2 3 Rank 2.10 Rank size rule Source: based 011 Garner 1967: 327. 4 5 \ 103~--------~____~__-L__~L-__~~______~ 1U 102 Rank 1 03 10 4 29 TRADITIONAL LOCATION THEORY ~ ." QJ I .. +-' +-' QJ C QJ u C QJ I Y -..I - ..I l .!­ I.!- 0 o ." ~ 0 t o: 't­ : u.) Q c C ' ';::; Q.) t: 0 t § ~ ..... !:! .S .- ... >... t: -o 0 ~ c u .g- § ~~ II II ~ -.0 M ....-- .g E QJ ~ W ." ~ E ~~ ~ QJ -£ : ; ~ b.o ~ I .~ IS.. ~ I :::.:::: E ~ N cxl 0 I .!-!::! 0 Q.) ~"E ex: ciS 6 a' . ... c) . c: "i' .... "<1< .] ~ :l .. 55;:g c. ....,: 0­\ '" <U 0 .. .~ c \j ...c: .- ... J jU ~~~~ ~~~IS.. 0 .. I @ - ..I I a... I~ " -J Q.. cxl <:(:::lE @@G@ cU c: :0 < U ' "!j ...... i';l ~..8 '~ AUGUST LOSCH . .. <U u=:: .2! ~ QJ Even before Central Places i n Southern Germany was translated into English i n 1966, n umerous economic geographers were testing central place theory in a variety o f places, including the US a nd notably in the flat landscape o f southwestern Iowa, b ut also in Asia - including northern India a nd s outhern Sri Lanka, a mong others as well as in Australia a nd N ew Zealand, Mrica a nd Europe. As i n t he case o f t he rank size rule, the predicted perfectly ordered landscape o f theory was never realized in t he 'real w orld' a nd, in t he l anguage o f s ubsequent modeling, real places always 'deviations' from the predicted o r idealized patterns a nd m uch energy was expended trying to account for the deviations in order t o further refine the models. T he language o f deviation also alerts us t o t he more normative quality o f these models. Are linear rank size distributions o f cities a nd regular a nd orderly hierarchical landscapes o f cities and towns a nd their hinterlands more 'ideal' t han the so-called deviations? Is it better o r more proper t o have economic spaces organized in these regular a nd orderly ways? S hould urban a nd regional planning strive to counteract tendencies towards deviation from such order by enacting policies designed to economic landscapes more perfectly along the lines o f t hese models? I n m any c ountries, t he p attern o f urbanization has been such that an urban hierarchy based o n a p rimate city has emerged, w ith o ne d ominant metropolis a nd very few medium sized cities a nd towns. Urban primacy, especially in poorer countries, has been viewed as s omehow undesirable o r sub-optimal, for b oth e conomic a nd p olitical reasons, a nd t he m any attempts to plan for the development o f so-called secondary cities in developing countries can be understood in this context (see Rondinelli 1983 as o ne example). .. ~ ~ ::I Six years after Walter Christaller's book was published in Germany, a nd w ith W orld W ar T wo beginning, August Losch's (1906-45) The Economics o fLocation appeared in 1939. This weighty volume was 'written a mid privations a nd w ar' and, according to his biographers, Losch was a 'declared o pponent' o f t he Nazi regime who, sadly, died just as t he w ar e nded (Losch 1954: vii; F unck a nd P arr 1978: 1). Losch's book was translated into...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 01/24/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online