Wood___Roberts_2011_Tradional_Economic_G

The farmer johann h einrich v on t hlinen was

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: farmer - Johann H einrich v on T hlinen - was considering perhaps t hat m ost basic 16 TRADITIONAL ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHIES o f questions asked by economic geographers: w hy does this particular activity take place i n t his particular location? J OHANN H EINRICH V ON T HUNEN J ohann H einrich von Thiinen ( 1783-1850) is l auded as t he founder o f location analysis. H e is also variously celebrated as a p ioneering econometrician, an i mportant c ontributor t o political e conomy a nd a n agricultural economist. T hiinen d eveloped two m ain s trands o f reasoning. O ne was concerned with improving agriculture through a rational understanding o f the economics intensity and variety. The second concerned the calculation o f wages. Economists remember Thiinen for his work aimed at understanding the so-called 'natural wage' i n w hich he attempted to link labor productivity and pay Dempsey 1960). I ndeed, o n his agricultural estate i n M ecklenburg, Thiinen experimented w ith s ome modest profit sharing schemes involving the workers he employed. Thiinen himself was most passionate about his work o n wages, even having the formula he developed for the natural wage carved into his gravestone! However, for economic geographers it is T hiinen's work o n the rational use o f agricultural land that holds most interest. I t, like the work o n wages, was theoretically elaborated using the 'fiction' o f the isolated state and was empirically tested and refined using detailed data o n prices, costs a nd yields between 1810 a nd 1815 t hat Thiinen h ad c ompiled for his o wn estate. lhe Isolated State is t he title o f T hiinen' s famous work o f 1826. T he isolated state was arguably the first explicit model in economic geography. Model-building, as we shall see in s ubsequent c hapters, has been a m ethod f or e conomic g eographers. Thiinen's m odel is a m eaning an abstraction from reality, although - like all models - it bears the traces o f the model-builder's context: the flat farmland o f n orthern G ermany o n the fringes o f t he Baltic Sea. I t is also an idealization; representing an 'ideal' landscape, o ne o rdered o n t he p rinciples o f rationality a nd equality. As in his work o n wages, Thiinen imagined a society composed o f undifferentiated, rational individuals with perfect knowledge: 'every citizen knows his o wn b est interest a nd acts accordingly' TRADITIONAL LOCATION THEORY 1966: 194). T hiinen opens his b ook w ith the following instructions t o the reader: Imagine a very town, at the center o f a fertile plain which is crossed by no navigable river o r canal. Throughout the plain the soil is capable o f cultivation and o f the same fertility. Far from the town, the _ turns into an uncultivated wilderness which cuts o ff all communication between this State and the outside world. There are n o o ther towns o n t he plain. The central town must therefore supply the rural areas w ith all manufactured products, a nd i n return it will obtain all its provisions from the surrounding countryside. The mines t hat p rovide the State with salt a nd metals are near the central town which, as i t is the only one, we shall in future call simply ' the T own.' 7) imaginary state, situated o n a featureless or isotropic plain a nd centered o n a single town s urrounded b y its h interland w hich, i n t urn, was surrounded by 'wilderness.' H e w ent o n to ask: ' What p attern o f cultivation will take shape in these conditions? a nd h ow will the farming system o f different districts be affected by their distance from the Town?' (1966: I n providing answers to his questions, Thiinen assumed steady for crops a nd i nputs (such as m anure a nd and o nly o ne m ode o f t ransport the horse a nd c art assuming, i n t urn, t hat t ransport costs w ould be p roportional t o distance. T hiinen was interested i n calculating the ' rent' for land. Land rent was a function o f the value o f its crop or, in o ther words, the sale o f the product minus the costs o f production a nd transport t o market. For land located at various distances from the town Thiinen deduced what types o f agricultural land use would generate returns that would maximize the land rent a nd t hus the rational allocation o f l and uses around the town. For each crop, there was in effect a rent t hat c ould be ' bid,' a p oint e laborated by s ubsequent l ocation theorists such as W illiam Alonso (Figure 2.1). Thiinen was n ot o nly interested in the choice to be grown bur also in the farming system t hat w ould be adopted - or w hether i t w ould be rational to adopt a crop rotation system a nd a pply lare;e a mounts o f m anure t o Crop 1 (e.g. strawberries) ~ Crop 2 (e.g. wheat) o d istance from town/market Crop 1 Production Zone Crop 2 Production Zone Figure 2 .1 Bid rent functions for two crops Source: based on Alonso 1964: 40. enrich the soil o r not. Thiinen recognized that o n land near the market o r u rban center intensive agriculture would be the economically rational use. Land further away, and...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 01/24/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online