We will o utstrip k we cannot rely on a self

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: • Libertarian position on government intervention: market forces can solve problems -The market will take care of this : Market includes human t alent -Erlich: NO, humans are consuming so many resources. We will o utstrip K. We cannot rely on a self-regulating solution.. We must t ake preventative actions! 1 Paul Ehrlich, prominent neo Malthusian ecologist • Famous for The Population Bomb (1968) • Over consumption will exhaust K • Much media attention for dire predictions including famine and social collapse • Urged strong efforts by governments to curb birthrates; helped found Zero Population Growth -Urged gvmts to impose policy that moves towards 0 pop g rowth The first Ehrlich Simon wager: will resource prices rise due to scarcity? • 1980: Will market price of Ni, Sn, Cr, W, and Cu be higher or lower in 1990? • Ehrlich lost: all 5 metals became cheaper, mostly because of substitution -Erlich predicted that we are using all these metals at x rate -> finite amount -> we will run out -What he didnt consider: as Ni became more and more s carce, technological people (SIMON's argument) will s ubstitute the metals for other metals -Rising prices of Ni was an incentive to look for other metals instead. Erlich did not bank on this 5 20/03/2013 The Simon David South wager: will resource prices rise due to scarcity? • 1996: Will market price of lumber rise or fall over 5 years? • Simon lost, and paid up early… • …but blamed the pinko Canadian government for manipulating markets! -Trees are a renewable resource, but we must har vest s ustainably -Prices went UP! (opposite of Ni situation) The second (proposed) Ehrlich Simon wager, 1994: will selected conditions affecting humans get worse or better? • Temperatures warmer • More atmospheric CO2, N2O, ozone, SO2 • Less fertile cropland per person; less agricultural soil per person; less rice and wheat per person • In developing countries, less firewood per pe...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 01/27/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online