Item mexico slash burn labour 7665 444 tools machines

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: Less needed, supplied by irrigation & fertilizer • Less needed, protection conferred by insecticides & fungicides 19 20 5 3/25/2013 Energy budgets for 2 styles of maize production (kcal x 102; Pimentel, Cornell) Crop type annual wheat versus perennial wheat: which is better? Item Mexico slash & burn Labour 7665 444 Tools, machines 166 1300 Seeds Inputs Big root systems can scavenge scarce H2O & NPK, don’t need them provided. Shed roots enrich soil. Lack of tillage prevents erosion. USA mechanized 468 540 Fuel 1270 N fertilizer 2400 P fertilizer 227 K fertilizer 155 Lime 135 Pesticides 1100 Drying grain 800 Electricity 100 Transport Output Grain 97 1944 kg 8000 kg 21 22 - Comparing output and input shows us that we must supply a LOT of input to generate these high outputs -There is a significant cost to this type of production -Note that the input in the Mexican Slash & Burn style of f arming does not even COMPARE to the input in mechanized f arming -Perennial versions of today's grain crops could be developed -These versions could make agriculture more sustainable -These crops would not require tilling of the soil each year -This will reduce the loss of soil and degradation -Perennial plants provide protection to the soil :) Modern agriculture depends on energy subsidies Economic & political implications • Energy content of cornflakes used to be solar • Now it includes much gasoline, diesel, natural gas, hydro, coal, nukes • The crowning absurdity: now replacing gasoline with ethanol from corn because of quirky American politics 23 -Use oil to fertilize corn -> har vest corn -> use it to power cars in p lace of gas -> MAKES NO SENSE! • Cost of food tied to cost of petroleum & electricity • China and India subsidize costs of N fertilizer to farmers • With current technology, increasing food supply requires burning more fuel and clearing more land 24 -This is a basic problem that we're having -We have exhausted our resources that make agriculture a good s olution to increasing food supply, but we have not found a p ermanent solution that is SUSTAINABLE 6 3/25/2013 How sustainable is modern, high intensity agriculture? • Petroleum subsidies are huge (replaced sunlight by oil) • Water requirements huge but supplies limited, running out in some places • Fertilizer (N expensive, P&K limited) • Irrigation often damages soil • Soil erosion • All of these will interact with climate change 25 7...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 01/27/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online