This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.
Unformatted text preview: ng these different values. Some of the values diversity, competition, and experimentalism - appear to depend significantly on the existence
of many states pursuing unique regulatory agendas. If all of the states pursued identical
regulatory strategies, or were prevented from instituting meaningful agendas altogether, these
values, as a logical matter, could not be promoted. Obviously there would be no regulatory
diversity, because all of the states would structure the lives of their citizens in the same way.
Moreover, this uniformity would prevent state competition and experimentation: people would
have no incentive to "vote with their feet" if each state provided the same package of public
goods, and experimentation by definition requires that different states attempt different
solutions to the same social problems.
[____] Federal Infrastructure spending distorts investment, undermining infrastructure
Chris Edwards, director of tax policy studies at the Cato Institute, 2011
(“Federal Infrastructure Investment,” http://www.cato.org/publications/congressionaltestimony/federal-infrastructure-investment)
There are calls today for more federal spending on infrastructure, but advocates seem to
overlook the downsides of past federal efforts. Certainly, there have been federal infrastructure
successes, but there has also been a history of pork barrel politics and bureaucratic bungling
in federal investment spending. A substantial portion of federal infrastructure spending has
gone to low-value and dubious activities. I've examined spending by the two oldest federal
infrastructure agencies — the Army Corps of Engineers and the Bureau of Reclamation. 7 While both
of those agencies constructed some impressive projects, they have also been known for proceeding
with uneconomic boondoggles, fudging the analyses of proposed projects, and spending on activities
that serve private interests rather than the general public interest. (I am referring to the Civil Works
part of the Corps here). Federal infrastructure projects have often suffered from large cost
overruns. Highway projects, energy projects, airport projects, and air traffic control projects
have ended up costing far more than originally promised.
7|Page States CP BDL
Answers to: Counterplan Not Educational/Not Real World [____] [____] There is a real world debate about what level of government should pay for
The Transportation Politic, 2012
(February 16, Clearing it Up on Federal Transportation Expenditures,”
The reaction to President Obama’s 2013 budget for transportation has ranged from the dismissive —
“it’s too big to be part of the discussion” — to the supportive (myself, among others), most of the
commentary revolving around the proposed program’s large size. Another theme, however, has
reemerged in the discussion: The role of the federal government in funding transportation. It’s
not a new conversation, of course; in American transportation circles, the roles of the...
View Full Document
This document was uploaded on 02/06/2014.
- Spring '14