DB2- Attestation Update - A&A for CPAs

It doesnt feel good to me is a really poor argument i

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: rit of the general principle, I know who will win. “It doesn’t feel good to me” is a really poor argument. “I just don’t like it” won’t carry much weight with an audit committee either. An argument at the margin of a particular accounting treatment won’t be influenced in the least by strong capital markets, any concern for S EC regulation, or a moments thought of private litigation. S omeone pushing for an imaginative accounting treatment will have already concluded the position will obvi ousl y be accepted by the markets, the S EC, and the courts. All that is left is to persuade that pesky audit partner that those silly rules do not prohibit this treatment. S uch is the power of rationalization. The only people in the argument will be the CFO and the audit partner. Without the backup of GAAP-based rules, the argument will be decided by whoever has the stronger personality. And t hat is not an improvement in the reporting regimen. By the way, how did that S EC enforcement work with Madoff? How did that fear of litigation work with Tyco, WorldCom, HealthS outh, etc., ad nauseum? Transitioning from a rules-based GAAP accounting model to a judgment- and principles-based IFRS will not be an improvement. http://attestationupdate.com/2011/06/28/ar g uments- for - adopting - ifr s- ar e- weak- ar g uments- ag ainst- have- validity- ther efor e- we- obviously- should- adopt- ifr s/ 2/4 1/23/2014 Ar g...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 03/06/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online