This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.
Unformatted text preview: and BCI Employees Workers UnionPAFLU" a motion praying for the
dissolution of the ex parte writ of preliminary injunction issued therein, wherein the following appears:
In that case, the CIR transfered the contactual rights of the BBWU to the defendant union. One of such
rights transferred was the right to the modified unionshop — checked off union dues arrangement now under
injunction. 40 The collective bargaining contract mentioned in the plaintiff's complaint did not expire by the mere fact that
the defendant union was certified as bargaining agent in place of the BBWU. The Court of Industrial
Relations in the case above mentioned made it clear that the collective bargaining contract would be
respected unless and until the parties act otherwise. In effect, the defendant union by act of subrogation
took the place of the BBWU as the UNION referred to in the contract. (Emphasis supplied)
There is no estoppel. UNION did not assert the above statement against BENGUET to force it to rely upon
the same to effect the union checkoff in its favor. UNION and BENGUET were together as codefendants in
said Civil Case No. 1150. Rather, the statement was directed against Bobok Lumber Jack Ass'n., plaintiff
therein, to weaken its cause of action. Moreover, BENGUET did not rely upon said statement. What
prompted Bobok Lumber Jack Ass'n. to file the complaint for declaratory relief was the fact that "... the
defendants [UNION and BENGUET] are planning to agree to the continuation of a modified union shop in the
three camps mentioned above without giving the employees concerned the opportunity to express their
wishes on the matter ..." BENGUET even went further in its answer filed on October 18, 1962, by asserting
that "... defendants have already agreed to the continuation of the modified union shop provision in the
collective bargaining agreement...."
Neither can we accept BENGUET's contention that the inclusion of said aforequoted motion in the record on
appeal filed in said Civil Cas...
View Full Document
- Fall '14