0 2 2 what to do 46348 texaco accepts counter 5

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: court award In strategic decision context, informa-on value can be nega-ve! 23 General Principles •  EVPI ≥ EVII ≥ 0 is true only in non- strategic problem instances. •  Timing of informa-on maeers. •  Informa-on that is revealed earlier is generally more valuable. •  The above may not be true in strategic decision- making instances. •  More examples to follow when we study game theory. 24 Problem 12.13 •  What if Liedtke could learn both Texaco’s reac-on and final court decision before making up his mind about the $2 Bn offer on the table? •  Why is the value of both pieces of informa-on more than the sum of their individual values? 25 Problem 12.13 EVPI = 5.23 – 4.63 = 0.6 Bn No-ce that Texaco’s response had no value by itself Is this surprising? Explain why? 26 Why? •  Informa-on about Texaco’s reac-on was not valuable by itself because Liedtke’s op-mal decision with or without this informa-on was to counteroffer $5 Bn •  With both pieces of informa-on, Liedtke can fine tune his response, especially when award is 0. •  In par-cular, Liedtke counteroffers if Texaco will accept $5 Bn, accepts $2 Bn if Texaco will refuse, and accept the $3 Bn counteroffer if Texaco will counteroffer. •  Such a refined strategy is not possible with only one piece of informa-on. 27 Texaco- Pennzoil Minicase (p. 558) •  What if Liedtke could influence outcomes? •  How much will he be willing to pay to influence Kinnear? 28 Texaco- Pennzoil Revisited Expected value of wizardry = EMV (with control) – EMV(without control) = 5 – 4.63 = 0.37 Bn Hugh has a lot to gain from influencing Kinnear and should be willing to spend a hepy sum to do so. Please note this is illegal! 29 14.14, Risk Sensi-ve DM 30 Decision Tree with U-li-es Liedtke should s2ll counteroffer, but i...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 03/12/2014 for the course IE 5545 at Minnesota.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online