Sim plification als o works by trans form ing groups

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: d. Sim plification als o works by trans form ing groups into es s ences , abs tractions endowed with the capacity to rem ain unchanged through tim e. In s om e cas es , people actually act as though the group has rem ained unchanged and talk, for exam ple, about the his tory of nations and com m unities as if thes e entities s urvived for centuries without changing, with the s am e ways of acting and thinking, the s am e des ires , anxieties , and as pirations . Paradoxically, precis ely becaus e identity repres ents a s im plifying fiction, creating uniform groups out of dis parate people, that identity perform s a cognitive function. It enables us to put nam es to ours elves and others , form s om e idea of who we are and who others are, and as certain the place we occupy along with the others in the world and s ociety. The current ups urge to as s ert the identity of groups can thus be partly explained by the cognitive function perform ed by identity. However, that s aid, people would not go along as they do, often in large num bers , with the propos itions put to them , in s pite of the s acrifices they entail, if there was not a very s trong feeling of need for identity, a need to take s tock of things and know "who we are", "where we com e from ", and "where we are going". Identity is thus a neces s ity in a cons tantly changing world, but it can als o be a potent s ource of' violence and dis ruption. How can thes e two contradictory as pects of identity be reconciled? Firs t, we m us t bear the arbitrary nature of identity categories in m ind, not with a view to elim inating all form s of identification—which would be unrealis tic s ince identity is a cognitive neces s ity—but s im ply to rem ind ours elves that each of us has s everal identities at the s am e tim e. Second, s ince tears of nos talgia are being s hed over the pas t, we recognis e that culture is cons tantly being recreated by cobbling together fres h and original elem ents and counter-cultures . There are in our own country a large num ber of s yncretic cults wherein m odem elem ents are blended with traditional values or people of different com m unities venerate s aints or divinities of particular faiths . Such cults and m ovem ents are characteris ed by a continual inflow and outflow of m em bers which prevent them from taking on a s elf-perpetuating exis tence of their own and hold out hope for the future, indeed, perhaps for the only pos s ible future. Finally, the nation-s tate m us t res pond to the identity urges of its cons tituent com m unities and to their legitim ate ques t for s ecurity and s ocial jus tice. It m us t do s o by inventing what the French philos opher and s ociologis t, Raym ond Aron, called "peace through law". That would guarantee jus tice both to the s tate as a whole and its parts , and res pect the claim s of both reas on and em otions . The problem is one of reconciling nationalis t dem ands with the exercis e of dem ocracy. 40. According to the author, happines s of indi...
View Full Document

This document was uploaded on 03/23/2014.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online