Until the mid 1930s, the courts accepted relatively few things as commerce. But since then,
the Supreme Court has greatly expanded the reach of the Commerce Clause and
has interpreted commerce to include almost any business activity
.
Individual states may also pass laws that regulate commercial activities. California might
pass a strict regulation that makes it illegal to sell a product in the state that can be legally
sold elsewhere in America. State regulations of commerce are typically legal if they do not
conflict with any of the doctrines listed below.
Federal preemption
The Supremacy Clause in the Constitution makes federal law the supreme law of the land.
In cases of express preemption, Congress creates a statute and specifically bans states
from creating similar laws. The doctrine of implied preemption may also block states from
creating valid laws even when Congress does not specifically prohibit such actions.

Congress can also engage in
express preemption
by specifying in the legislature that the
states have no power to adopt similar laws. There’s also implied preemption.
Discrimination against interstate commerce
If Texas tried to pass a law that made it illegal to sell oil from Texas to buyers in other
states, the law would fail for discriminating against interstate commerce.
Unduly burdening interstate commerce
States also cannot pass laws that create significant roadblocks to interstate commerce. The
Internet has opened new frontiers in this area of the law as the
Granholm v. Heald
case in
the reading illustrates.
**Commerce clause only concerns economic activity (
US v. Lopez
and
US v. Morrison
)
There are two other constitutional limitations on the discretion of states: (1)
full faith and
credit clause
says that the courts of one state must recognize court judgments and other
public actions of its sister states, and (2)
contract clause
applies to the states but not the
federal government and is intended to prevent states from changing the terms of existing
contracts by passage of subsequent legislation.
4. Constitutional Liberties
In addition to setting up the government, the Constitution guarantees fundamental rights
that may not be abridged. Everyone is at least reasonably familiar with the notion that we
have a right to free speech and religious worship, a right to be free from unreasonable
search and seizure, and a right to an attorney if we are accused of a crime.
All of the rights in the Constitution apply when the federal government commits a wrong.
Also, many of them apply to states and local governments under the doctrine of
incorporation, which uses the phrase due process in the 14th Amendment to stretch the
application of many Constitutional liberties beyond the federal government as described in
the reading assignment.


You've reached the end of your free preview.
Want to read all 61 pages?
- Spring '08
- BREDESON
- Law, Common Law, Supreme Court of the United States