Prescription Falsification lines 59100 Judge Uh how old are you Defendant

Prescription falsification lines 59100 judge uh how

This preview shows page 15 - 17 out of 39 pages.

Prescription Falsification (lines 59—100) Judge: Uh how old are you? Defendant: Thirty-four. Judge: Where do you live? Where is your home? Defendant: Uh my hometown is ( ). That’s where my wife and family [2 secs] fare right now.! Judge: /All right.! How long have you been in Tucson? Defendant: Totally, about one year, but just before last Christmas, we moved back to ( ). Judge: Uh these incidents uh apparently relate to- Well, one of them relates to an incident that occurred last August of seventy-seven, and the second one uh ( ) prescription drug charge to uh an incident on July eighteen, 1977.WereyouinTucsonatthattime?
Image of page 15
IdeologicalStancesinTakingGuiltyPleas63Judge:/Uhwhat!Defendant:/Mostof!myjobshavebeenadministrativetypethings.Judge:Where,specifically,wereyouworkinghereinTucson?Defendant:ForU-Totemstores.[2secsJJudge:UhyoudoreadandunderstandtheEnglishlanguage.Defendant:Yes,Ido.Judge:Howmucheducationhaveyouhad,Mr.Appleton?Defendant:Twoyears().Thisisthetypeofexchangetherecord-orientedjudgeswouldratheravoid,andtheycanavoidsuchexchangesbynotaskingthequestionsinthefirstplace.Thus,bothbehaviorallyandideologically,anissuethatiselaboratedonfortheprocedure-orientedjudgesisabbreviatedfortherecord-orientedjudges.ConstitutionalRightsAllthejudgesinformthedefendantsoftheirconstitutionalrights.Noneofthem“haveto,”accordingtothecaselawdiscussedinchapter3,becauseallthecaselawrequiresisthattherebeevidenceintherecordthatdefendantswereinformedoftheirconstitutionalrights,andsuchevidenceisample.Theconstitutionalrightsarespelledoutkinthewrittenpleaagreementandwhendefendantssignthepleaagreement,theyareverifyingthattheyhavereaditscontents.Defendantsarethenaskedduringtheprocedureiftheyhavereadandsignedthepleaagreement,whichthejudgealsoholdsinhishandandchecksforasignatureduringtheprocedure.Sometimesdefendantsarealsoaskediftheyhavediscussedthepleaagreementwiththeirlawyersandiftheyunderstandit.Thereisonthisissue,then,greatredundancyintherecordprovidingevidencethatdefendantsknowandunderstandtheconstitutionalrightstheyarewaivingbypleadingguilty.Nevertheless,ineveryinstanceofthisprocedureinmydatabase,allthejudgesinformedthedefendantsoftheirrightsandaskediftheyunderstoodthem.Evenso,procedure-orientedjudgesengagedinmoreelaborateexchangeswithdefendantsthandidrecord-orientedjudgestoinformthemoftheserightshndmakesuretheyunderstoodwhattheyweregivingup.Inthefollowingtwotranscriptexcerpts,IpresenttheabbreviatedversionoftherightsfromJudge4andthentheelaborateversionoftherights
Image of page 16
Image of page 17

You've reached the end of your free preview.

Want to read all 39 pages?

  • Spring '18
  • LEE
  • Pleas, Plea

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture