4.
The Methods section in this article is pretty challenging because it contains
descriptions of complex measures like the visuo-spatial task switch test. Try not to
get bogged down in the details of these measures. The important idea here is to
understand in general what the four groups were and what variables they tried to
measure in each group. This table might help make it clear:
Group
age
VO
2
max
BMI
switch
costs
switch RT
sedentary
46.92
28.68
27.93
654.3
654.3
aerobic
44.09
45.66
23.78
400.84
489.63
meditation
48.63
41.83
23.3
401.23
477.41
t’ai chi
55.4
34.14
29.3
14.13
453.94

PSY 250
MPW
The idea is that each cell in the table could be filled in with their data, so we'd
know how, for example, meditators compared to aerobic exercisers in terms
of BMI.
If you had to summarize the methodology of this study, how would
you say it?
In other words, what did they do in the study in order to collect
their data? 2 points
They tested aerobic capacity through measuring each participants VO2 Max
through a 1-mile walk. They tested executive attention through a complex
visuospatial task switch test, which measured switch RT and switch
capacity/percent switch costs. They measured each participants BMI and
recorded their BMIs. Through their design of the experiment, the researchers
carefully defined groups that could provide data to support/refute their
hypotheses.
5.
Do you know anyone who meditates or does
t’ai chi
? Let's say I know someone who
meditates but, in my opinion, she's not very quick mentally. In fact, I've seen her
really struggle to follow a conversation and she gets confused easily.
Do you think
my friend’s mental abilities (or limitations) invalidate or refute the results
of this study?
2 points
No, because the results of an experiment are supposed to explain the major
trend in a
relationship. It does not account for every single case, so your friend
would be an exception to this trend.


You've reached the end of your free preview.
Want to read all 5 pages?
- Fall '08
- Gore,J
- Cooper test, t’ai chi