Before the lab was over, each student was required to enter in their initial and final masses of
each nail so that the GTF could calculate the mean and deviation of the mass lost, percent of mass
lost and mass lost per mm
2
.
Table 2: Class Data
Mass Zinc Lost(g)
% Mass
Lost(%)
Mass
Lost(g)/mm
2
Average
0.10g
11.5
0.00045
Deviation
0.04
3.8
0.00017
These calculations were done using a MS Excel spread sheet and shortcut calculations. This data
shows that in a larger sample the mass lost per surface area is 0.00045+/ 0.00017 g/mm
2
, which
is closer to the industrial standard than my individual data.
Discussion/ Conclusion
After analyzing the data collected from the five nails I analyzed and comparing it to the data
collected by the class (all together 100 nails) it is clear that the more nails included in the average,
the more accurate the data is. My average of g/mm
2
was 0.0005 g/mm
2
with a deviation of 0.0001
while the class average was 0.00045 g/mm
2
with a deviation of 0.00017. The national standard for
galvanized nails is 0.000305 g/mm
2
. If I were just analyzing my data then I would determine that
this batch does not meet the standard, but because I am also comparing the class data, the batch of
nails could be considered within the range of the standard. I conclude that the more nails
examined, the more accurate the g/mm
2
thus in order to make a completely true analysis I would
This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.
View Full Document
need to test the entire batch. The magnitude of the standard deviations shows that there is a wide
range of uncertainty due to error in this lab.
I found this lab to have a wide range of error, some that can be removed, others that can only be
reduced. The indeterminate error in this experiment is the fact that we cannot fully dissolve the
zinc without knowing how much zinc there is on each nail before hand. We can estimate how
long it needs to react but without knowing the total mass, and without the zinc being completely
uniform we will either not completely dissolve the zinc or some iron could begin to dissolve. This
affects the entire lab so that the exact g/mm
2
will not be determined. That is why the more nails
This is the end of the preview.
Sign up
to
access the rest of the document.
 Fall '12
 DeborahExton.(TAHaoboWang)
 Chemistry, Green Chemistry, nails, Zinc Lost

Click to edit the document details