°Three huge trolls are sitting next to the fire, complaining loudly that they have only mutton and not “manflesh” to eat. Bilbo knows that, as a burglar, he is supposed to pick their pockets or steal their meat—or simply kill them so he and his companions can spend the night by their fire. He doesnot know how to do these things, but he does not want to go back to the dwarves with nothing to show for his efforts. After spending quite some time gathering courage, he slips toward one of the trolls, William, and tries to steal his purse—but gets caught. William grabs Bilbo, and the three trolls immediately begin arguing about whether such a small creature is worth killing and eating. The argument quickly devolves into a brawl.°The trolls drop Bilbo, who crawls out of the way. By now the dwarves have heard the commotion, so they decide to come investigate. One by one, each of them creeps toward the fire. Balin arrives first, and the trolls pounce on him and tie him up in a bag. They step into the shadows and pounce on each of the other dwarves in turn. Thorin arrives last and best prepared. He fights the trolls, injuring two of them with a flaming log. Bilbo tries to trip one, but he is too weak; he just gets flung into a nearby bush. The trolls bag Thorin up with the other dwarves and sit back down by the fire, resuming their argument about how to cook and eat their captives.°Just as the trolls decide to roast the dwarves, Gandalf arrives. He stays hidden but joins the conversation, impersonating the voices of the trolls. He gets them to start arguing again, and he keeps them talking so long that eventually the sun comes up and turns them all to stone. Then Gandalf frees Bilbo and the dwarves, and they all go looking for the trolls’ cave. In it they find gold, a bit of food, and some weapons. Gandalf and Thorin each take a sword, and Bilbo takes a knife that is long enough to work as a sword for him.