RESEARCH CRITIQUE 7 fatigue The overall workload scale can be used as a quick

Research critique 7 fatigue the overall workload

This preview shows page 7 - 9 out of 10 pages.

RESEARCH CRITIQUE 7 fatigue. The overall workload scale can be used as a quick screening tool. Another point of interest that was not discussed might be to define ITL for each nurse. Does it mean they want to leave nursing altogether? Or does it mean they want to leave their current area in hopes of finding somewhere where there are better working conditions and less stress? Limitations The authors identified several limitations of this study. The study was cross-sectional, measuring fatigue level at only one point in time, making it impossible to determine how fatigue changed and what influenced that change. The study did not use random sampling method, limiting the generalizability of the results. The one-item SRHS scale might not be sensitive enough for healthy workers. Increasing the sample size would increase the instrument options. The study did not include organizational factors, such as co-worker support or leadership style, which might increase the amount of explained variance of ITL (Liu et al., 2016). Generalization of Findings This study demonstrates how personal characteristics, such as health, work conditions, and work fatigue can affect ITL in new nurses. It has also been shown that work conditions, such as working overtime and excessive workload, can directly impact nurses’ ITL. Nursing is a very demanding career, both physically and mentally, and nurses have a higher need for recovery. In this study, the average working hours for nurses were around 10 hours per day, with some reaching as high as 16 hours. Working more than 10 hours resulted in acute and chronic fatigue among nurses with less recovery compared to those working less than 10 hours. These nurses were also required to do homework and to review literature for problems that they encountered or for questions their preceptors asked. New nurses seemed to have little down time for adequate rest outside of work. The inability to withdraw from work obligations would also contribute to
Image of page 7
RESEARCH CRITIQUE 8 increased fatigue and poor recovery. With less recovery time, nurses might develop chronic fatigue, which was the dominant type among new nurses (Liu et al., 2016). Suggestions for Further Study According to Liu (2016), future studies should focus on the longitudinal change of work- related fatigue. This would allow researchers to find trends in fatigue changes and develop interventional strategies. Format Current APA format was used in writing this article. No spelling or grammatical errors were noted. The article was clearly organized in a way that made it easy for the reader to understand the study. Part II: Comparison and Analysis Design Quantitative research design was appropriate for this study and there was no intervention or treatment described. The strength of this research is that it is both a descriptive and correlational non-interventional design. It describes the variables in detail and focuses on the relationship between and among the variables (Gray et al., 2017). The limitations of the study
Image of page 8
Image of page 9

You've reached the end of your free preview.

Want to read all 10 pages?

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture