10041007; Menocal 1982: 146147). The
proposal has another, equally unfortunate,
consequence. Having been pushed aside as the
source of trobar2, trobador, etc., *tropare
would be left to compete with turbare as the
etymon of trouver/trobar1 find alone. On
 right up to a high, diphthongized [I]). Of
particular interest is the discovery by
anthropological Interpreting language variation
and change 253 linguists that the phenomenon
of variation is by no means limited to such
settings. Consider, for example,
201236. Cambridge, MA: MIT. Corne, Chris.
1983. Commentaire sur Chaudenson 1983.
Etudes Creoles 6(2): 2259. Corris, Peter.
1973. Passage, port and plantation: a history of
Solomon Islands migration, 18701904.
Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Crago,
anthropology. In P. K. Bock (ed.), Psychological
anthropology, 12137. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Barney, Rachel. 1998. Socrates Agonistes: the
case of the Cratylus etymologies. Oxford
Studies in Ancient Philosophy 16: 6398. Barth,
Fredrik (ed.). 1969. Ethnic
R., C. Cazden, and U. Bellugi. 1968. The childs
grammar from i to iii. In J. P. Hill (ed.), The
second annual Minnesota symposium on child
psychology. Minneapolis: University of
Minnesota Press, 2873. Brown, Roger
Langham. 1967. Wilhelm von Humboldts
surprisingly, therefore, divergent points of view
comparable to those that enlivened
etymological debates have surfaced in the
sociolinguistic community. Some researchers
have emphasized the role of universal or nearuniversal constraints on the direction
complex ways (Labov 1981, 1994). The shift of
the vowel in bad, mentioned above, is an
example of the first type of change in the
speech communities of those North American
cities where the radical restructuration of the
vowel system known as the Northern
grecque: histoire des mots. (Nouv. tirage).
Paris: Klincksieck. Chao, Yuen-Ren. 1976.
Philosophical perspectives. Aspects of
Chinese sociolinguistics. Selected and
Introduced by Anwar S. Dil. Stanford: Stanford
University Press. Chatterjee, Ranjit. 1985.
Publication no. 35. Ehrlich, Susan and Ruth
King. 1996. Consensual sex or sexual
harassment: negotiating meaning. In Bergvall,
Bing, and Freed (eds.), Rethinking Language,
153172. London: Longman. Eisenberg, A.
1986. Teasing: verbal play in two Mexican
(and more generally, that between orthodox
Neo-grammarians and those linguists who, like
Schuchardt, consider all linguistic change,
whether phonetic, morphosyntactic, or
semantic, as a fundamentally social
phenomenon) can be usefully examined from
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fishman, Joshua (ed.). 1968.Readings in the
sociology of language.The Hague: Mouton.
Fodor, Jerry A. 1983. Modularity of mind: an
essay on faculty psychology. Cambridge, MA:
MIT Press. Foley, William A. 1988. Languag
resistance or, more fundamentally, between a
positivist epistemology and a hermeneutics
appropriate to the human and historical
sciences. But is it necessarily a bad thing if
sociolinguistics brings both naturalscientific and
hermeneutic approaches to bea
participation frameworks within boys and girls
disputes. In D. Tannen (ed.), Gender, 110143.
New York: Oxford University Press. Goody,
Esther. 1995. Social intelligence and interaction.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Goody,
Jack. 1977. The domesti
semantic fields, as guides in the reconstruction
of certain types of lexical sets, such as kinship
terminology (Friedrich 1979; Benveniste 1969).
In addition to the above factors, hypotheses are
evaluated for the range of cases they cover, the
number of u
fundamental component of the etymological
method. It is for this reason, as Meillet (1954:
104), Malkiel (1977), and Anttila (1988: 7677)
have acknowledged, that etymology is an art, or
craft, as much as it is a science, and that
recognition as a master p
1999;Aerts 2000). The effect is magnified if the
readers of these reconstructions, 248 Kevin
Tuite or the leadership of the institutions
sponsoring the scholars research, share the
authors prejudices. Politically motivated
amateur etymologies are depressi
gender. In di Leonardo (ed.), Gender at the
Crossroads of Knowledge, 175203. Berkeley:
University of California Press. 1993. Diversity
and contestation in linguistic ideologies:
German speakers in Hungary. Language in
Society 22(3): 337360. 1995. Lost in
Anthropology, 31: 339361. Palo Alto: Annual
Reviews Inc. Geertz, Clifford. 1973. The
interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic
Books. 1986. Works and lives: the
anthropologist as author. Stanford: Stanford
University Press. Genesee, F. 1989. Early
socialization across cultures, 213250.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1999.
The socialization of affect in Japanese mother
child conversation. Journal of Pragmatics
31(11): 13971421. Clancy, P. M., N. Akatsuka,
and S. Strauss. 1997. Deontic modali
doing so enables them to formulate sound laws
(the lowering of high vowels in closed syllables,
and the affricatization of the dental stops
before high front vowels), which account in an
elegant way for thousands of similar cases: [dis]
and [dzis] ten, [d
3. 1977. Outline of a theory of practice.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1983.
Vous avez dit populaire? Actes de la
recherche en sciences sociales 46: 98105.
Bowerman, Melissa. 1985. What shapes
childrens grammars? In D. I. Slobin (ed.), The
conventional shorthand to specify the regular
correspondences among Old English hweol,
Greek kuklos, Sanskrit cakra- , Tocharian
kukal , etc., and little interest is taken in how it
might have been pronounced (Pulgram 1959).
Others credit reconstructed fo
1999. Language creation and language change:
creolization, diachrony and development.
Boaston: MIT Press. 2001. In Kenttale: a life in
language, ed. Michael Keastowicz. Cambridge,
MA: MIT University Press, pp. 53121. 2003.
Against creole exceptionalism. L
concerning the formation and constraining of
hypotheses. I will add two further issues
relating to historical methodology to Wylies
list: (1) What it is that makes an account
explanatory, and what evidence constitutes
grounds for accepting an hypothesis.
reviewed: regularity and irregularity in language
change, 135156. New York: Oxford University
Press. Boas, Franz. 1887 (1974). Museums of
ethnology and their classification. In George W.
Stocking, Jr. (ed.), The shaping of American
Schieffelin and E. Ochs (eds.), Language
socialization across cultures, 5179. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press. Deprez, Christine.
1994. Les enfants bilingues: langues et familles.
Paris: Didier. Derrida, Jacques. 1967. La
structure, le signe et le j
Fraser, Nancy. 1993. Rethinking the public
sphere: a contribution to the critique of actually
existing democracy. In Craig Calhoun (ed.),
Habermas and the public sphere, 109142.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Freud, Sigmund.
1989. Totem and taboo. New York: No
authors erudition and investigative zeal. But in
the final analysis, such an etymology is
successful to the degree that it draws the
readers themselves into the project of
interpretation. This endeavor requires them to
apply their imaginations, and instin
development of cognitive anthropology.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
DAndrade, Roy and Claudia Strauss (eds.).
1992. Human motives and cultural models.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Daniel,
E. Valentine and Jeffrey M. Peck. 1996.
precise, does not yield the sort of results that
would encourage traditionally trained linguists
to continue their inquiry. (3) The enforcing of
high standards of erudition and familiarity with
neighboring disciplines considered relevant for